SkepticblogSkepticblog logo banner

top navigation:

Wooing away the oil leak

by Phil Plait, May 12 2010

A man in Boulder — yes, my home town — is trying to meditate the oil leak away. His idea?

"The basic concept is to try and get as many people to visualize that the valve is actually functioning and is working and closing."

This is part of the Intention Experiment, what is basically telekinesis:

Lynne McTaggart, who started the Intention Experiment, has organized more than a half dozen mind-over-matter experiments — most recently to try to improve the water quality in Lake Biwa, Japan — that involve people focusing their thoughts on something in the physical world to make change. She claims to have scientific evidence that it works.

Scientific evidence? Really? I wonder if she’s interested in making a quick million bucks.

Look, we’ve seen this before. People have prayed for rain, and tried to pray the stock market into obedience. These efforts fail, always. Or at best they might coincidentally align with some event, but it’s never clear in advance just what event they were aiming at (making it easy for them to claim success after the fact).

I know that people who believe in this sort of thing have their heart in the right place. I’m frustrated by horrific events like the oil leak too, and I wish I could do something tangible. But trying to pray it away won’t work. One believer said this:

"I completely understand that most people would have a healthy skepticism about these things," said Jahnavi Stenflo, also of Boulder, in an e-mail. "To all those skeptics, I would simply ask them to participate in the exercise if they would like to try. … Ultimately, there is nothing to lose in trying to visualize the valve shutting off. It either will help or it will not."

These "What’s the Harm?" arguments are extremely misleading. Of course there is something to lose. This kind of thing has been tested over and again, and shown to be a waste of time. The time spent by the participants is one obvious thing lost. But more than that, what we lose when we do things like this is our ability to separate fantasy from reality. And we do know quite a bit about human behavior: people who will try to meditate the oil leak away will almost certainly not conclude meditation doesn’t work when it fails. Instead they’ll find excuses why it didn’t work, and try it again next time something happens.

The more we wish for something to be true, the more we must hold it up to scrutiny lest we fool ourselves.

I am not saying things like this shouldn’t be tested. The point is, they already have been. Repeatedly. And they never work. If this oil leak is to be stopped, it’ll have to be done using engineering, using science, using actual physical work. And at the moment there’s not much you or I or anyone outside of the engineers at BP can do to help.

However, I’ll add that thinking about the problem is important. When the root causes of the leak are found — and I don’t mean the physical problems, but what failures allowed the situation to arise in the first place, both in the company and in the political environment — we need to make sure that it doesn’t happen again. That means keeping up with the news, being aware of the situation, and contacting politicians so that they hear our voices about it.

That is where thinking makes a difference.

Recommended Reading

20 Responses to “Wooing away the oil leak”

  1. Max says:

    They should start small, like meditating away the oil leak in an old car.

  2. BillMassey says:

    This group needs a catchy slogan, a la “Pray Away the Gay.”

    I’m thinking: “Muse to Lose the Ooze”

  3. Robo Sapien says:

    I think you’re being a bit too critical, Mr. Plait. While mass meditation won’t fix the valve and clean up the spill, it will give a warm and fuzzy feeling to the engineers who are fixing it. How would YOU like to clean up an oil spill without feeling warm and fuzzy? I don’t think you’d care for it much.

    • Max says:

      So the meditators can take credit when the engineers fix the leak.

      • Majority of One says:

        I felt all warm and fuzzy today. They must have sent their energy toward the gulf and it hit me instead,thanks Depak.

        I hate it when that happens.

  4. Max says:

    Instead of focusing attention on the oil leak, we should all ignore it, because according to Deepak Chopra, if nobody observes it, it doesn’t exist.

    • Max says:

      Or we could clean it up with a single drop of oil in the ocean, according to homeopathy principles.

  5. Skepticon says:

    “Look, we’ve seen this before. People have prayed for rain, and tried to pray the stock market into obedience.”

    These kooks “praying” for rain, a market jump or to staunch the flow of oil into the Gulf of Mexico should do what the climate alarmists have done: develop a computer model that shows “it” to be so.

    • Max says:

      The Wall Street Journal cited a study where stock traders were told that they could affect stock prices by pressing the ‘X’ and ‘C’ keys on the keyboard. The strength of their belief in this bogus claim was negatively correlated with their real life earnings.

  6. Maybe if we all concentrate really hard we can make the woo go away.

  7. Beelzebud says:

    No more crazy than right-wingers like Limbaugh and Beck blaming the catastrophe on environmentalists.

  8. rob says:

    to speak up for woo this may be the first case where homeopathy would work. if only we had a couple of solar systems worth of water tto get it to about 30c

  9. kj says:

    Meh. Seems to me that science has developed new technologies and disproved beliefs which had previously been called fact because science had said so.

    Maybe science is incapable of measuring the benefits or drawbacks of an exercise like the Intention Experiment. Maybe an MVP basketball player visualizing himself sinking three-pointers is just silly.

    And maybe it’s just good for people to do and believe that which feels right for them, so long as we’re not harming one another.

  10. Oil Boom says:

    I love the line, “…visualize that the valve is actually functioning and is working and closing.”

    Didn’t the oil pipe blow apart below the level of any closing valve?

  11. Donna Gore says:

    Isn’t pot legal in Colorado now?????

  12. JP says:

    Will Baby Will!

    The problem with wackos like this is that eventually…eventually she will succeed. We just have to wait long enough for the prayers (nature, physics and time) to do their job.